2017 HSC Section 2 - Practice Management

Annals of Surgery Volume 258, Number 6, December 2013

Russ et al

( continued )

Gynecology and orthopedics

laparoscopic

cholecystectomy

procedures only

Authors Year Type of Checklist Outcome Assessed ∗ Study Methodology † Country Setting Surgical Specialty General surgery

Multispecialty

Cardiovascular

center

USA, Alaska 1 rural community hospital

USA 1 tertiary academic center

hospital

UK, Leeds 1 university hospital Cardiac surgery

2 Swedish hospitals Multispecialty

Ostergotland

USA, Baltimore 1 tertiary academic

Israel, Jerusalem 1 tertiary care Sweden,

USA, Virginia 1 university hospital General surgery—

360 ◦ ratings of self and peers (real ORs)—pre/post

Surveys—post (Data collection commenced 15 months after checklist implementation) Observations (real ORs)—pre/post

(Data collection lasted for 3 weeks 1 yr after the checklist had been implemented)

(No information was provided regarding timings)

(The study lasted 7 months in total. No additional

information regarding timings provided.)

(Postobservations were carried out 7 days after briefing implementation) Observations (real ORs)—pre/post

(preobservations lasted 3 months, postobservations in gynecology took place 5 months later and lasted 3 months, observations in

orthopedics took place 10 months later and lasted 3 months)

Surveys and observations (from video recordings of real ORs)—RCT

(The study lasted 15 months in total.)

Quality of teamwork (eg, team orientation, accountability, communication)

communication and teamwork

Surgical flow disruptions related to miscommunication

Near-misses associated with problematic teamwork

“Team feeling” in the OR Surveys—post Team coordination and communication.

Interdisciplinary

Quality of communication Interviews—Post

preoperative briefing checklist

preoperative briefing and postoperative

de-briefing checklist

preoperative briefing checklist

preoperative briefing checklist (presented

in poster format in all ORs)

Checklist

preoperative briefing and postoperative

de-briefing checklist

checklist with pre-, intra-, and postoperative components

Paige et al 31 2008 Patient-specific

Berenholtz 32 2009 1-page, patient-specific, Henrickson et al 33 2009 Patient-specific

Einav et al 34 2010 Patient-specific

Nilsson et al 35 2010 WHO Surgical Safety

Papaspyros et al 36 2010 Patient-specific

Calland et al 37 2011 Patient-specific safety

TABLE 1. ( Continued )

www.annalsofsurgery.com

C 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins

166