xRead - Olfactory Disorders (September 2023)

20426984, 2022, 4, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/alr.22929, Wiley Online Library on [04/09/2023]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License

529

PATEL et al.

TABLE VIII.10 (Continued)

Age,mean (SDor range), year

No. of patients (male/female)

Correlation coefficients

Study groups Healthy patients

Correlated tests UPSIT R vs butanol threshold UPSIT R vsT&T detection threshold (composite) UPSIT R vs T&T ID test (composite) UPSIT R vs. Yes:No discrimination test

P value

Study author

Dotyet al, 1994 1105

45.8 (20.2)

37/60

0.41

0.001

0.41

0.001

0.61

0.001

0.60

0.001

0.29

0.001

UPSIT R vs odor

intensity rating test (slope)

UPSIT R vs odor

0.27

0.001

intensity rating test (mean)

UPSIT R vsPEMEC threshold

0.49

0.001

UPSIT R vsPEA

0.63

0.001

threshold (scaling factor reversed)

UPSIT R vs odor

0.59

0.001

discrimination test

UPSIT R vs odor memory test

0.62

0.001

49.5 (18.5)

55/52

Healthy patients

SS-ID vs SS-T (butanol) 0.54

0.001

Hummel et al, 1997 1235

SS-ID vs SS-D

0.56

0.001 0.001 0.001 0.001

SS-T (butanol) vs SS-D 0.66 SS-ID vs CCCRC ID test 0.50

SS-ID vs CCCRC

0.24

threshold (butanol)

SS-T vs CCCRC ID test 0.38

0.001 0.001

SS-T vs CCCRC

0.34

threshold (butanol)

SS-D vs CCCRC ID 0.35

0.001 0.001

SS-D vs CCCRC threshold

0.31

CCCRC ID vs CCCRC threshold T&T detection vs UPSIT R T&T recognition vs UPSIT R UPSIT R vs SOIT CCCRC threshold vs SOIT Odor ID vs n-butanol threshold

0.29

0.001

38.2

40/40

S&T clinic patients

0.53

0.001

Kondo et al, 1998 1242

0.70

0.001

(15–79)

21/21

Healthy patients

0.76

0.001

Nordin et al, 1998 1158

0.60

0.001

38.4 (18–90) 31/65

Healthy patients

0.31

0.01

Lehrner et al, 1999 1236

Odor ID vs odor memory

0.69

0.01

(Continues)